Showing posts with label medical care. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medical care. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 1, 2007

May 2007 MCS America News: Sal's Place - Psychiatric Diagnoses are Not Based on Science

I recently read a news article entitled "Prominent Psychiatrist Forced to Finally Concede that Psychiatric Diagnoses are Not Based on Science". My first thought was AMEN to that!

Then the topic began to bug me. I began to think that we can't call MCS "science" because there is no clinical test and it's diagnosed based on subjective observation and patient reported symptoms. However, psychiatric disorders (or otherwise "normal behavior" in most cases) are called "science" yet there are no clinical tests and diagnosis is based on subjective observation and patient reported symptoms.

This reminds me of an eye opening observation when I was at the beach park yesterday. I had returned to my van where I saw a bird and it was following me around the van, no more than 2 feet away from me, as I moved about drying off and fixing my hair. I figured it was a brave bird and probably very hungry so I dug up some quick oats from the van and scattered them around the ground and soil for the bird to eat. Soon, dozens were there partaking in the "feast".

I watched with apt curiosity as they moved around each other, never touching, pecking as fast as they could at each oat without any fighting. One bird with a red cap of another species pecked much faster than the others and I soon realized it was not eating the oats, but holding them in it's mouth to carry away and feed it's hatchlings housed in a nest in the tree I parked next to.

I had not realized I was standing so still, motionless, until I moved and all the birds instantly retreated several feet farther from me and stopped eating. I again stood still and they slowly, nervously returned to eat as fast as they could with an ever watchful eye on me. Each time I moved, they scattered again, so I eventually moved to the other side of the van and allowed them to enjoy their feast in peace.

I bring this up because it struck me as a "normal" instinctual behavior to protect the species from predators, that psychiatry would label as a "phobia" of humans or motion.

It also struck me that, like the birds shared, I shared. The birds did not know when their next feast would be or when they might happen upon food again. Yet they did not fight over the food. Like them, I did not think twice about giving them a whole serving of oats that should have been my breakfast one morning even though I'm very low on food and have no errand runner or prospects for one in the near future. I, like them, do not know if there will be food in a few days. Yet I shared it with a hungry bird.

Isn't humanity fascinating when we stop trying to label others and appreciate how human nature is normal and has an inherent biological purpose? We need each other to survive in community, so we feed each other. Birds need to be wary of predators in the wild so they scatter and run when there is motion near them or another species approaches. These are normal, instinctual behaviors, not psychiatric disorders. The birds don't have general anxiety disorder or people phobia any more than I have "feel sorry for hungry birds syndrome". We're just normal creatures feeling, operating, and doing as our creator made us. Emotions are normal occurrences. To say otherwise would say the whole flock of birds was mentally ill... a far fetch. Yet, that is exactly what psychiatry has done to humans with a push to sell expensive and dangerous psychopharmaceuticals. We are taught our emotions are wrong and that we should be numb. How and why have things gone so wrong?

Copyrighted © 2007 MCS America

May 2007 MCS America News: Healing Modalities: Massage

Massage involves the application of pressure and motion through touch to the soft tissues of the body, including lymphatic to achieve a beneficial response. While many enjoy massage as a simple means of relaxation, it is also touted to increase lymphatic drainage and increase blood flow, bringing oxygen and nutrients into the tissues. Massage has also been shown to improve autistic behavior, relieve anxiety and depression, increase healing after surgery, improve growth in premature infants, increase attention and focus, reduce muscle tension, and reduce blood pressure.

A study entitled Perceived Treatment Efficacy for Conventional and Alternative Therapies Reported by Persons with Multiple Chemical Sensitivities, in which Gibson et al (2003) found that fifty-nine percent of subjects felt that massage helped with the symptoms of multiple chemical sensitivities (MCS). This is reasonable considering that massage increases nutrients and oxygen in the tissues which would likely reduce fatigue and brain fog. Additional blood flow helps to cleanse the body and possibly relieve some of the body burden of toxins carried.

Since endorphins (natural pain killers) are released during massage, it is also a useful therapy for pain reduction and may be useful for fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue. The combination of relaxation, endorphins, nutrients and oxygenation is likely to produce a positive effect in most subjects.

Massage is popular, not for these effects, but for the sheer pleasure of touch being used to reduce tension and relax muscles. However, as we discovered, massage is not only pampering and rejuvenating, but also highly therapeutic!

See you on the massage table!

Reference:

Gibson, PR, Elms, NM, & Ruding, LA (2003). Perceived Treatment Efficacy for Conventional and Alternative Therapies Reported by Persons with Multiple Chemical Sensitivities. Environmental Health Perspectives. 111(12):1498-1504.

Copyrighted © 2007 MCS America

May 2007 MCS America News: Living in a Toxic World. Do You Know What Counts?

Often times we are trusting beyond belief. But when does trust become dangerous? Try this quiz:

What year is your car?

What make is your car?

What model is your car?

What color paint is on your car?

How many cylinders does it have?

What kind of gas do you put into your car?

How many miles are on the odometer?

How many miles to the gallon does your car get?

How often should you change the oil in your car?

What kind of tires are on your car?

What kind of interior does your car have?

What color is the interior of your car?

Now:

What is in the vaccination that the doctor is about to inject into your child?

What is in the amalgam filling the dentist is about to put in your child's mouth?

The Autism Society of America (2007) defines autism as a complex developmental disability that typically appears during the first three years of life and is the result of a neurological disorder that affects the normal functioning of the brain, impacting development in the areas of social interaction and communication skills. Both children and adults with autism typically show difficulties in verbal and non-verbal communication, social interactions, and leisure or play activities.

Autism currently affects 1 in 150 children according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2007) and is one of five disorders known as Pervasive Developmental Disorders (PDD) which include: Autistic Disorder, Asperger's Disorder, Childhood Disintegrative Disorder (CDD), Rett's Disorder, and PDD-Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS).

Parents across the world have come forth blaming their children's autism on the MMR vaccination or vaccinations which contains thimerosal, a form of mercury. Though it is controversial whether there is any connection, the reality is that the symptoms of autism are nearly identical to those of mercury poisoning (Bernard et al, 2000). Further, it may well be a form of toxic injury, or multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS).

Slimak performed a study of in 49 autistic children. "Elimination of food-related reactions entirely allowed effects of environmental chemicals to be thoroughly studied indefinitely in the absence of food-related symptoms. Initially unaffected by social contexts, the autistic subjects acted out the ways they were affected by their environment without the altering effects of societal influences; and severity of the adverse effects made observation and study easier. There was a strong correlation (P<.000) between environmental exposure levels and autistic symptoms and behaviors. There appeared to be nothing inherently wrong with autistic children studied. The children in the program (universal diet and clean room) returned to normal physically, in temperament, in awareness of surroundings and others, in emotions and empathy, and in ability to learn. Based on the results of the present study, a broad spectrum of severe and chronic autistic symptoms appear to be environmentally based, apparently caused by chronic exposure to volatile organic compounds, and appear to be fully reversible in the proper environment" (Simak, 2003, Abstract).

MCS America suggests that parents take the time to learn about autism and research vaccination safety. There is too much coincidence in the increase of autism and other neurodevopmental disorders since the inception of vaccinations. These conditions were virtually unheard of before vaccines become commonplace. This is truly an epidemic situation. Autism is now known in every race, every income level, every education level, and both genders.

The new webpage located at: http://mcs-america.org/index_files/VaccinesMercuryAutism.htm

References:

Autism Society of America. Retrieved on April 8, 2007 from: http://www.autism-society.org/site/PageServer?pagename=about_whatis_home

Bernard, S, Enayati, A, Binstock, Roger, H, Redwood, L, & McGinnis, W. Autism: A Unique Type of Mercury Poisoning. ARC Research. 2000.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Retrieved on April 8, 2007 from: http://www.cdc.gov/

Slimak, K. 2003. Reduction of autistic traits following dietary intervention and elimination of exposure to environmental substances. In Proceedings of 2003 International Symposium on Indoor Air Quality and Health Hazards, National Institute of Environmental Health Science, USA, and Architectural Institute of Japan, January 8-11, 2003, Tokyo, Japan, 2:206-216.

Copyrighted © 2007 MCS America

May 2007 MCS America News: Legal Persecution Part 3

Part 3 of a 3 part series:

In review… after a brief consult with an infectious disease doctor who did not conduct any tests, my son and I were diagnosed by her alone, with a shared psychotic disorder she remembered from medical school. Despite the blood work results, scans, and cultures given to her with our initial paperwork, she belittled the doctors we had seen and their diagnoses, interrogated my son regarding my so-called mood swings, and called our medical history "crap". Disturbed by her bizarre demeanor, we left her office, after receiving our unfounded diagnosis, filed a complaint with the state medical board, and were subsequently turned into Child Protective Services for an alarming look into a very broken and scary system which haunted us for the next six months.

Month after month of Constitutional due process rights violations at every turn, moving to another county in the same state, lost dollars spent on legal fees that didn't get us an inch closer to justice we were about to encounter yet another CPS hearing to see how this new court investigator would paint the picture, in a county where the abuse/neglect allegations were proclaimed totally unfounded by one of their own social workers.

Part III

After previous hearings where I was denied putting my medical documentation, doctors' letters, and reports on the record and denied my testimony on the stand, my son and I waited in a secluded room to avoid the overwhelming perfumes and colognes which permeated the premises. My court appointed attorney came into the room asking, "Have you seen the report?" "No," I stated numbly as I lifted my head from my arms which rested on the table. She then handed me a copy of the court investigator's report stating that my son was thriving in my care and I was providing appropriate housing, education, and medical care. The fabrication had stopped! One person in a very broken system actually had it right! The report was later presented to the judge that day, and all parties asked that the jurisdiction be dropped. The judge granted the requests and thus we were finally free! Or were we?

I am still on a child abuse index and will remain there for ten years. If I am to ever work in my profession in the future, as a teacher, I will be denied working with children as long as my name remains on the index. Even when the first county had the report from our new county of residence stating the allegations were unfounded, the judge still took jurisdiction. The previous county had an agenda and the judge was biased about environmental illness. If I want to get off of the index it will take yet another lawyer, more legal fees, and more stress! There is only one lawyer to my knowledge, who has successfully challenged the index. Who should be held accountable for the loss of potential income? The reporting doctor? CPS? Both?

Another element of this ordeal is my appeal in the first county which is still pending. I am still waiting for my appeal lawyer to find the judge's decision was based on his personal or the county's agenda to shut down my pending worker's compensation case, or to prevent me from filing a case against the county on my son's behalf. However, how can my appeal lawyer prove these things when the transcripts have been changed? Who is to be held accountable for tampering with official documentation? Do I pursue another case? It's evident that many cases can develop out of one seemingly simply case.

What lessons did I learn? First and foremost, one must never go to a doctor with chronic symptoms unless referred by a trusted physician. Secondly, every parent in America needs to set up a legal standby guardianship today so no financial incentives prevail for any agency to intervene and take a child on unfounded grounds. Next, medical documentation is private and confidential and no school should convince/coerce any parent otherwise.

In addition, every parent should carry a pocket recorder everywhere to record any conversation which might be misconstrued later. This would include conversations /interviews with doctors, social workers, and lawyers. Check state codes for taping hearings/trials. Many people counseled me regarding this step and I didn't believe I needed to do it, however I have learned that their counsel was appropriate and needed.

Lastly, every parent and child should have an updated passport on hand. If our guaranteed Constitutional rights are not being recognized and upheld in this country, no matter the amount of energy, time, money is put forth to find justice, then one must contemplate alternatives. Align with like minded citizens and groups who promote Constitutional rights being upheld, and actively seek accountability from those who continue to abuse their positions of power.

In conclusion, my son and I did not ask for the environmental health consequences of asbestos exposure, gas leaks, water intrusion, mold exposure, chemicals injected in heating systems and other compromising exposures. None of us with chronic illness would ever wish to earn only a fraction of our earlier professional compensation, or to avoid going to places we used to frequent and socialize, to be forced to only eat certain foods, wear certain clothing, buy certain bedding, purchase specialized chemical free expensive products, and devote most of our energy just to surviving. Losing my career, my health, and my son's health was an extremely overwhelming life transition to deal with. But the thought of losing my son because of a doctor's unspoken agenda was outrageous and at times too much to handle. No mother in America should ever have to deal with this sort of legal persecution!

-Christi Howarth

Copyrighted © 2007 MCS America


May 2007 MCS America News: Scientific Studies: Non-Immune Contact Reactions

One of the frequent misunderstandings about multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS) is confusing it with an allergic response due to IgE (immunoglobulin E). MCS is not an allergic reaction. Rather, it appears to be a reaction to the toxic properties of the incitants due to a damaged detoxification system. Thus far, science is still searching for the existence of biomarkers to diagnose the condition.


Researchers conducted a study involving non-immune immediate contact reactions (NIICR), which are defined as "non-immunoglobulin E (IgE)- mediated skin responses that occur without previous sensitization" (Harth et all, 2007). NIICR has been observed from contact with benzoic acid, trans-cinnamic acid and methyl nicotinate as well as cinnamic aldehyde of fragrance mix. Antihistamine treatment in these cases has been ineffective because the reaction is non-immune or NIICR.




The researchers examined a case report of a subject with workplace related reactions to perfumes. The subject presented delayed reactions to a mixture of odorous substances in patch testing. A bronchial challenge with perfume was performed and yielded an immediate asthmatic reaction with a diagnosis of occupational allergy to perfumes.




The researches tested a 47 year old female gardener who complained of shortness of breath and headaches when exposed to any and all odors since 2000. The patient experienced the symptoms at home and work, though they were more pronounced at work. The diagnosis of idiopathic environmental intolerance (IEI) was the most likely diagnosis, though the researchers decided to perform further tests.




For the first time, the researchers applied an NIICR inducing component of fragrance mix in a bronchial challenge test which showed an asthmatic reaction. The symptoms were determined to not be due to hyperosmia (oversensitivity to smell). It was determined that the negative results for asthma favored the diagnoses of the accidental coincidence of IEI and NIICR. Though the researchers did not find a cause for IEI, the did determine that cinnamic aldehyde has effects of the lower airways of the patient and that bronchial effects and clinical relevance of NIICR need to be further examined.




This study reinforces the fact that environmental illness is not allergy mediated or asthma related., yet there may be co-occurring allergy or asthma in some patients.




Reference:




Harth V, Merget R, Altmann L, & Bruning T. Bronchial challenge testing to fragrance component as further diagnostic approach to non-immune immediate contact reactions.. Contact Dermatitis. 2007 Mar;56(3):175-7.




Copyrighted © 2007 MCS America

May 2007 MCS America News: Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) and Genetics

Millions of people all over the world, including small children, have developed Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) upon exposure to toxic chemicals in the environment. Due to the incessantly growing number of the worldwide general population stricken by MCS upon exposure to toxic chemicals, MCS has become one of the most serious and overlooked public health problem in the world. But what causes this terrible hypersensitivity to chemicals and other substances in the environment for millions of people of any race, gender, age, and national origin? Why is it that millions of these people, who lived normal lives, until one day a chemical exposure, ranging anywhere from pesticides, insecticides, fumigants, building renovations, installation of new carpeting, fresh paint… the list could go on almost endlessly, started to develop reactions from mild to severe.

The wide variety of symptoms experienced by persons with MCS has puzzled everybody, including the medical profession, for decades and the medical profession is unprepared to deal with such occurrence of a worldwide epidemic of this environmentally induced disease. However, regardless of the large variety of symptoms experienced by persons suffering from MCS, there tends to be a definite pattern of neurological, respiratory and cardiac symptoms.1

Pesticides2, especially organophosphates pesticides and insecticides, among so many other neurotoxic chemicals, are playing a major role in triggering MCS. According to the environmental medicine publication, Environmental Health Perspectives, a survey in September 2003 showed indeed, that about one third of persons developed MCS after being exposed to pesticides and another third developed MCS after being exposed to solvents.3

Many research studies have been done on MCS, among them the SPECT brain Scan, with sponsors including the US Department of Health and Human Services, which found that MCS patients exposed to neurotoxic chemicals indicated a random thinning of cortical gray matter (tissue in the cortex of the brain). The researchers made the very important conclusion that symptomatic MCS patients with an history of exposures to chemicals, had significantly diminished cerebral blood flow to the brain, and that significant impairment of brain function may last for years after exposure to neurotoxic chemicals has ceased.4,5

Some other studies are indicative that persons with MCS have little or no brain barrier that protects them from damages from low-level chemical exposures due to an excess of peroxynitrite (Pall M. 2001) that breaks down the blood barrier, therefore allowing greater access to the brain of persons afflicted by MCS. The more there is an excess of peroxynitrite, the more there is an inhibition of cytochrome P450, which means that it slows down the body's natural detoxification process. Nitric oxide inhibits cytochrome P450 activity, thus slowing degradation of hydrophobic organic chemicals (Pall, 2003).6, 7

These findings can explain the reactivity of persons with MCS to even minute doses of chemical exposures to which the non-MCS population would not react to. The combination of reduced or non-existent blood brain barrier and impaired detoxifying process of persons with MCS may induce long term, and even permanent brain and central nervous system damage, which can include toxic encephalopathy.

It also has been found that brain inflammation corresponds with symptoms of MCS. In 1999, Meggs came to the conclusion that Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) is potentially caused by low molecular weight chemicals, binding to chemoreceptors on sensory nerve C-fibers, thus leading to the release of inflammatory mediators.8

Others studies also showed certain vitamins and minerals deficiencies, abnormal lipid and carbohydrate metabolism.9 In 2005. Gibson suggested limbic kindling, neural sensitization, and neurogenic inflammation upon exposures to various pesticides, volatile organic compounds, solvents and other toxic compounds.10

However, all these very interesting findings are rather secondary effects of MCS in a vulnerable population, and do not really reveal the true cause of MCS. So what is the real cause of Multiple Chemical Sensitivity? The real cause of MCS may lie in the susceptibility of genes. This may be why, even though we are all exposed daily to toxic chemicals in the environment, millions of people have developed MCS, while millions of others not only did not develop MCS, but have been totally unaffected by exposures to toxic/neurotoxic chemicals in the environment.

An individual with normal genes will be very resistant to exposures to toxic/neurotoxic chemicals in the environment, while an individual with gentic variants will have very little resistance to exposures to toxic/neurotoxic chemicals in the environment, which explains why millions of people all over the world have developed MCS versus millions of others who have not. This determines how the body responds to exposures to chemicals. Certain segments of the population are generally more sensitive including the very young, the old and people with compromised immune systems or livers. Men and women may respond differently to chemical exposures and are at risk for different adverse health effects.11

Because of their genetic makeup some people are more susceptible to chemical exposures than others. The adverse health effect of chemicals depends on their toxicity and how people are exposed to the chemicals, as well as individual susceptibility. Exposures to toxic chemicals can lead to a very wide range of health effects which may take place immediately or may take very long time to develop, which include impairment of the immune system, genetic damage (mutagenicity) and inhibition of the body's ability to breakdown chemicals.13, 14, 16

Persons with MCS have a genetic susceptibility to toxic chemicals found in the environment. In other words they have gene variants that make them vulnerable to exposures to toxic chemicals in the environment. These abnormal genes impair the detoxifying process in the MCS population, which in turn has the consequence of bio-accumulation of toxic chemicals in the body (body burden). Once the body has reached its saturation point, any subsequent exposure to any chemicals will trigger the symptoms of Multiple Chemical Sensitivity. The accumulation of toxic/neurotoxic chemicals in the body of persons with MCS may explain the characteristics of the symptoms of neurotoxicity experienced by all persons afflicted by severe MCS.

There lies an answer to the puzzle of Multiple Chemical Sensitivity. Now, let's look scientifically into how genetics apply to Multiple Chemical Sensitivity. Genetic factors seem to contribute to virtually every human disease. The majority of diseases are influenced by multiples genes and environmental factors. Genetic variation plays a role in whether an individual has a higher or lower risk for getting a particular illness.12.

The DNA sequence in every human being is 99.9 % percent identical to the one of every other human. The slight variation in our genes is known as single nucleotide polymorphisms or SNPS. It is estimated by scientists that there are about 1.4 million locations on the genome, where SNPS can possibly occur in humans. Small variations contribute to individual differences and can also be triggered by toxic substances in the environment. Some SNPS can cause or predispose a person to disease or influence the person's response drugs.11

Some human illnesses and defects are directly or indirectly caused by genetics abnormalities. Some other illnesses however are caused by complex interacting genetics and environmental factors that cannot be explained by inheritance patterns,11 We may inherit a specific condition, as well as the particular ability to respond to environmental stresses such as bacteria, viruses and environmental toxins.11,12 Understanding how DNA can influence every health aspect will hopefully and eventually lead to effective ways to prevent, treat, and cure thousands of diseases afflicting humankind.

Genes are pieces of DNA that hold instructions for building a particular protein. Proteins are most essential for all aspects of life. Through these proteins, our genes dictate how we look, how we respond to infections, how well we process our foods, and detoxify poisons. Harmful DNA variations, called mutations, can cause or constitute many different disease and conditions. It depends on their size and location, and they can be devastating;11, 12

An interesting scientific study done in Israel, "A transcription –activating polymorphism in the ACHE promoter associated with acute sensitivity to anti-acetylcholinesterases", by Michael Shapira et. al, showed that chemical hypersensitivity to xenobiotics causes adverse responses to normally subacute levels of a specific chemical or a group of chemicals. Persons afflicted with this abnormality may suffer from an exaggerated immune response showing itself as inflammation of mucosal and epithelial tissues. They may also alternatively show abnormal capacity for scavenging, modifying or degrading relevant chemicals.17

The aberrantly processed chemicals may in turn cause toxicological stress in target tissues with many symptoms of varying nature and timing according to the tissue, the type of exposure, and the actual permeability of the chemicals.

The mutations that lead to such faulty chemical metabolism were identified largely within the coding regions and consequently affecting the detoxifying protein properties. However, the impaired transcriptional activation of genes responsible for detoxification, because of their regulatory sequences, may be an equally important cause of chemical hypersensitivity. For instance, the metal-chelating metallothioneins, and some of the members of the cytochrome P450 chemical-modifying enzyme family, respond to exposure to xenobiotics by transcriptional activation, which is responsible for increased protection. The most significant finding thus, is that impaired transcriptional activation due to promoter polymorphisms in these genes would be then the cause of chemical hypersensitivity.17

In another extremely interesting scientific study, researchers at the University of California, Berkley and the University of Washington have found that some newborns can be 26 to 50 times more susceptible to certain organophosphates pesticides and 65 to 130 times more sensitive than adults.16 The study also revealed much greater variability in susceptibility to pesticides, than it was previously predicted. The researchers used the activity levels of paraoxonase 1 (PON1) measured in blood samples as a marker for pesticides susceptibility.16

PON1 is an enzyme whose function is to break down the toxic metabolites of organophosphate pesticides. Research Professor, Clement Furlong in the Department of Medicine and Genome Sciences at the University of Washington and co-lead author of the paper, had found the significance of PON1 in prior animal studies.16 In these studies, mice that lacked the PON1 enzyme died when exposed to low levels of organophosphates pesticides, while the other mice with normal levels of the enzyme PON1 and given the same dose did not develop any symptoms at all. Both the quality and quantity of the PON1 enzyme is very important in determining the ability to detoxify pesticides.16

What is extremely significant for the MCS population is that the ability of the PON1 enzyme to protect the body from the toxicity of pesticides is determined by genetics, more specifically, whether a person has the Q or R form of the PON1 gene at position 192 on the chromosome.16

In addition to the factors that affect the type of PON1 enzyme, there are also additional genetic variants that affect the levels of enzyme available. People have remarkable differences in enzymes that defend their health from toxic pesticides exposures.16

A very important, most recent, cross-sectional study19 of self-reported - related sensitivity, conducted by Eckart Schnakenberg, Institute for Pharmacogenenetic and Genetic Disposition, Langenhagen, Germany, Karl-Rainer Fabig, Nathalie Fabig, Clinical Practice for Toxicology and Environmental Medicine, Hamburg, Germany, Martin Stanulla, Children's Hospital, Pediatric Hematology and Oncology, Hannover Medical School, Hannover, Germany, Nils Strobl, Michael Lustig, Werner Schloot, Center for Human Genetics and Genetic Counseling, University of Bremen, Bremen, Germany, analyzed genetic variants of the NAT2, GSTM1,GSTT1, and GSTP1 genes.

The result showed evidence of significant differences between individuals with and without self-reported chemical-sensitivity in regard to the distribution of NAT2, GSTM1, and GSTT1 gene variants. Cases with self-reported chemical-related sensitivity were quite significantly more frequently NAT2 slow acetylators. GSTM1 and GSTT1 genes were very significantly more often homozygously deleted in the individuals who were reporting sensitivity to chemicals in comparison to controls, and the effects for GSTP1 gene variants were observed in conjunction with GSTM1, GSTT1 and NAT2 gene.

In conclusion, the results from this study population show that individuals who are slow acetylators and/or having a homozygous GSTM1 and/or GSTT1 deletion reported more frequently chemical-related hypersensitivity, thus providing the genetic evidence of MCS.

Brenda Eskenazi of the University of California, Berkley, Professor of Epidemiology and Director of the Center for Children's Environmental Health Research said "Our next step is to look at the relationship between pesticides exposure and neurodevelopment, specifically for young children and genetically susceptible populations".

On of the most significant scientific genetic findings for the MCS population is the Case-control study of genotypes in Multiple Chemical Sensitivity: CYP2D6, NAT2, PON1 and MTHFR, conducted by: Gail Mckeown-Eyssen,18 Department of Public Health Sciences, University of Toronto, Department of Nutritional Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada, Cornelia Baines, Nicole Railey, Vartouhi Jazmaji, Department of Public Health Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada, David E.C. Cole, Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology, University of Toronto, Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Department of Pediatrics (Genetics), University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. Rachel F.Tyndale, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, Department of Pharmacology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada, Lynn Marshall, Environmental Health Clinic Unit, Women's College Hospital Toronto, Canada, Ambulatory care Center, Sunnybrook and Women's College Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, Canada.

The research team collected the blood samples of the 203 cases and 162 controls participating in the research for genetic analysis. They isolated genomic DNA and identified specific polymorphisms in order to determine the frequency of occurrence of certain polymorphisms, in cases compared to controls, for several genes that play major roles in how the body responds to chemicals. In their testing for different allele frequencies in specific genes, they found quite significant differences for the CYP2D6 (Cytochrome P450 2D6) gene and a marginally significant difference for the NAT2 gene.18

CYP2D6 is responsible for encoding enzymes that metabolizes many toxic chemicals as well as therapeutic drugs. Cytochrome P450 enzymes are a large group of enzymes that include a quite important part of the body's instruments to get rid of potentially harmful substances.18

NATI and NAT2 (N-acetyltransferases) are responsible for encoding enzymes needed for metabolizing toxic chemicals, different drugs, aromatic amines. PON (paraoxonase) are genes code for the products of proteins that react with toxins such as pesticides and nerve agents.18

MTHFR (methylenetetrahyrofolate reductase) is responsible for encoding a key enzyme involved in the metabolism of some B vitamins (including folate and B 12). MTHFR –C677T gene was studied because impaired vitamin B12 metabolism can contribute to neurological symptoms.18

The distribution of genotypes between cases and controls were significantly different for both the CYP2D6 and NAT2. The women who were homozygous for the active form of the gene CYP2D6, had over three times the risk of getting MCS compared to the women who were homozygous for the inactive form of CYP2D6. The women who were heterozygous for the active form of the gene CYP2D6, also showed an increased risk of developing MCS.18

This suggest a "gene-dose effect", with the risk of getting Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) increasing in respect to the number of active CYP2D6 alleles. The women who were homozygous for the fast form of the gene NAT2, (the 4 allele) called " rapid acetylators" had over four times the risk of getting Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) in comparison to slow acetylators who have a lack of the 4 allele of the gene NAT2. As for the women who were heterozygous, intermediate and had only one 4 allele, they did not show an increased risk.18

The most striking finding was that the women with genes that encodes rapid metabolism by both enzymes CYP2D6 homozygous active and NAT2 "rapid acetylator" genotypes, were over 18 times more likely to get MCS in comparison to the women with the slow metabolic forms.18

So in resume, in this epidemiology study, the researchers have reported an extremely important finding for the MCS population of several genetic differences between cases and controls in the genes involved in the detoxifying process of contaminants and that basically a genetic predisposition for MCS involves altered biotransformation of environmental chemicals.

Not only did they discover that indeed differences do exist, but also these differences were found in genes that are crucial to detoxifying toxic compounds, and that MCS patients are more likely to have the type of genes that would impair their ability to detoxify toxics themselves. When they looked at two genes at the same times, they found that women with MCS were over 18 times more likely than controls to have a very specific combination of forms of two separate genes.

Their data is the first of a kind to demonstrate such genetic differences in enzymes crucial for the detoxification of contaminants by comparing people with MCS to those who do not have MCS. It is thus providing strong genetic evidence for the physically- based occurrence of MCS.

The studies of Haley20 and Furlong20, of the Gulf War Veterans, which implicated the gene PON1, of Shapira17et al, of Schnakenberg19 et al involving three genes, and of Mc Keown-Eyssen18 and colleagues implicating five genes, show that one or more genes controlling the metabolism of compounds previously implicated in Multiple Chemical Sensitivity, control the occurrence of chemical sensitivity, thus providing the physical evidence of the genetic origin of Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) upon exposures to chemicals.

Due to the increasing magnitude of this pandemic environmentally induced disease affecting millions of people all over the world, further scientific genetic research must urgently be done in order to fully identify and understand all the genes variations and mechanisms that make the MCS population so susceptible to toxic chemicals and other substances in the environment.

Research into possible treatment, such as gene therapy, would hopefully be on its way to possibly prevent and even cure the millions of people from all over the world, suffering from the devastating health effects of MCS, and would be the scientific turning point for a better world for future generations.
- Christiane Tourtet


Coypright Christiane Tourtet © 2007


Printed with Author's Permission

Christiane Tourtet is a well-known free-lance, award winning Medical, Sciences, and Environmental writer, photo- journalist, photographer, and devoted Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) activist for over 20 years. She is the Founder and President of International MCS Awareness, and USA and Florida State Coordinator for MCS-Global. Her biography has been included in numerous world wide publications, notably in Who's Who in America and Who's Who in the World.


References
1. Joffres, MR, Sampalli ,T, & Fox, Roy (2005). Physiologic and symptomatic responses to low-level substances in individuals with and without chemical sensitivities, a randomized controlled blinded pilot booth study. Environmental Health Perspectives. 113: 9, 1178-1183.
2. Windham Bernard Ed- Health Effects of Pesticides, 6-1- 2001 Leon County Public Health Department. http://flcv.com/pesticid.html
3. Ferrie, H. (October 2003), Multiple Chemical Sensitivity: Government and Medical Science Finally Recognize Crippling effects of MCS, http://www.vitalitymagazine.com/node/112
4. Callender, TJ, et al (1995), Evaluation of chronic neurological sequelae after acute pesticide exposure using SPECT brain scan, Journal Toxicology & Environmental health.41:275-284.
5. Heuser, G, et. al. (1994), Neurospect findings in patients exposed to neurotoxic Chemicals, Toxicology & Industrial Health.10:561-57
6. Pall, M. (2001), Multiple Chemical Sensitivity-The End of the Controversy, Washington State University, School of Molecular Biosciences. http://molecular.biosciences.wsu.edu/faculty/pall/pall_mcs.htm
7. Pall, M. (2003), Elevated nitric oxide/peroxynitrite theory of Multiple Chemical Sensitivity: central role of N-Methyl-D-aspartate receptors in the sensitivity mechanism, Environmental Health Perspectives.111:12. 1461-1464.
8. Meggs, WJ (1999), Mechanisms of allergy and chemical sensitivity, Toxicology and Industrial Health.15:3-4,331-338.
9. Rea, WJ, Johnson, AR, Ross et. al. (2006), Considerations for the Diagnosis of Chemical Sensitivity. http://www.aehf.com/articles/A55.htm
10. Gibson,P. (2005), Understanding & Accommodating People with multiple Chemical Sensitivity in Everyday Living. Houston TX: Independent Living Research Utilization.
11. JGI, Doe Joint Genome Institute- US Department of Energy- Office of Science. http://www.jgi.doe.gov/index.html
12. National Human Genome Research Institute, National Institute of Health. http://www.genome.gov/education
13. Gilbert, S.G. 2001, An introduction to toxicology, A lecture given at "A Small Dose of Toxicology: How chemicals Affect Your health", a conference sponsored by the Northwest Center for Occupational Safety and Health, University of Washington, Oct.17
14. Dickey, P.2001, Toxicity of common household products. A lecture given at "A Small Dose of Toxicology: How Chemicals Affect Your Health", a conference sponsored by the Northwest Center for Occupational safety and Health, University of Washington, Oct.17.
15. Ponce, R. 2001, How chemicals attack cells, A lecture given at "A small Dose of Toxicology: How Chemicals Affect Your Health" a conference sponsored by the Northwest Center for Occupational Safety and Health, University of Washington, Oct.17.
16. Medical News Today, 01/12/2007, Public Health News, Some Newborns May Be 26 to 50 Times More Susceptible To Exposure To Certain Organophosphate Pesticides Than Other Newborns. http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/medicalnews.php?newsid=38839
17. Shapira Michael, et. al., A transcription–activating polymorphism in the ACHE promoter associated with acute sensitivity to anti-acetylcholinesterases, Human Molecular Genetics, 2000, Vol.9, No.9 1273-1281.
18. McKeown-Eyssen, G, C Baines, DEC Cole, N Riley, RF Tyndale, L. Marshall, V.Jazmaji.2004, Case-control study of genotypes in multiple chemical sensitivity: CYP2D6, NAT1, PONI, PON2, and NTHFR . International Journal of Epidemiology 33 (5): 1-8.
19. Schnakenberg Eckart et al, A cross-sectional study of self-reported chemical-related sensitivity is associated with gene variants of drug metabolizing enzymes, Environmental Health 2007, 6:6 doi: 10.1186/1476-069X-6-6.
20. Furlong Clement E., PON1 Status and Neurologic Symptoms Complexes in Gulf War Veterans, Genome Res.2000 10: 153-155.Retrieved on February 12, 2007 from www.genome.org

Blog Archive